Cover image for Professional philosophy : what it is and why it matters
Title:
Professional philosophy : what it is and why it matters
Personal Author:
Publication Information:
Dordrecht : D. Reidel Pub, 1986
ISBN:
9789027720719
Subject Term:

Available:*

Library
Item Barcode
Call Number
Material Type
Item Category 1
Status
Searching...
30000000474845 B72 P47 1986 Open Access Book Book
Searching...
Searching...
30000000474837 B72 P47 1986 Open Access Book Book
Searching...

On Order

Summary

Summary

Over the past several decades serious work in philosophy has become almost wholly inaccessible to people who do not specialize in the subject. To be sure, the writings of Aristotle and Kant were never easy reading, and even relatively untechnical philosophers like Mill or Santayana de­ mand careful study if we are really to understand them. But during the last generation or two the situation has steadily become worse for readers who may want to know what philosophers of their own time are doing. And this is true even though many writers have been learning to avoid the unnecessary jargon that disfigures so much of traditional philosophy. No matter how direct the English style of recent philosophers may be, their methodic purposes and argument style will re­ main obscure to anyone who has not gone to considerable trouble to be introduced to them. Then too, the closeness of their analysis and the con­ sequent narrowness of many of the issues pursued make it hard to catch onto the argument without some familiarity with slightly earlier discus­ sions from which those issues emerged. All of this helps to account for the rather common but false belief that professional philosophy is now only a collection of technical exercises that could hardly be of interest to anyone but the philosophers themselves.


Reviews 1

Choice Review

The purpose of this book is to explain and illustrate the contemporary analytic tradition in philosophy. It is not an introductory textbook, but an introduction in the sense of a travel guide cum apologia. It attempts a chronicle-by examining exemplary moments-of the development of analytic philosophy from the work of the early G.E. Moore through S. Kripke, with a separate attempt to do something similar in the area of value theory. The author claims to provide an adequate thematic and methodological overview of the analytic tradition; however, the absence of any serious discussion of logical positivism seriously vitiates this claim. The discussions of the work of individual philosophers are uneven and sometimes misleading; the author barely mentions Carnap. Although this book will likely interest a wide range of undergraduate majors and interested nonphilosophers seeking an overview of the analytic tradition in philosophy, libraries with limited resources should concentrate on acquiring the books and journals containing the original work of the authors Perry discusses.-W. Taschek, University of Michigan