Cover image for Ethical judgment in teaching
Title:
Ethical judgment in teaching
Personal Author:
Publication Information:
Boston : Allyn and Bacon, 1997
ISBN:
9780205174089

Available:*

Library
Item Barcode
Call Number
Material Type
Item Category 1
Status
Searching...
30000003883976 LB1779 H67 1997 Open Access Book Book
Searching...

On Order

Summary

Summary

This book is about helping teachers think carefully and knowledgeably about ethics in teaching, and to encourage them to talk to other people about it. Each chapter in the body of this text is organized around a pair of basic ethical concepts: freedom and discipline, self and others, communities near and far, excellence and equality, unity and diversity, and faith and truth. Each of these chapters begins with a realistic case, which provide a vehicle for readers to see how the concepts come up in concrete situations. Following each chapter case are two essays by two different contributing writers who put themselves in the position of deciding how to approach the case. The idea is for them to model ethical judgment and to give readers a glimpse into how thoughtful people may agree or disagree on the same case. The writers continue to respond to each other's reactions throughout the chapter, in order to show how constructive criticism of other people's viewpoints and the ability to provide feedback can help people learn from each other in a civil manner. This book presents a wider range of theoretical perspectives than its competitors, while offering actual exchanges of viewpoints between informed educators. The discussion is more philosophically sophisticated, and encourages readers to think critically and to incorporate theory into actual judgment. It aims to show the importance, as well as the limitations, of making judgment a cooperative activity among people. For professionals working in the field of education.


Table of Contents

Acknowledgments
1 Introduction
Case
Why Ethical Judgment?
Why Ethical Judgement?
The Plan of the Book
2 Freedom and Discipline
Case
Reflections on "Freedom and Discipline
"ShowdownNicholas Burbules
Is It Really Freedom and Discipline?Betty Sichel
First Reading and Thoughts
Second Reading and Thoughts
Andre's Response through My Voice
Notes
Further Reflections on "Freedom and Discipline
"Beyond Freedom and DisciplineNicholas Burbules
Right On, NickBetty Sichel
Discussion
Freedom as an Ethical Value
Conversation and Argument
Conclusion
3 Self and Others
Case
Reflections on "Self and Others
"Lucy's DilemmaNel Noddings
Her Self in Compromise: Carving a New Path of IntegrityDilafruz Williams
Confronting Voices and Choices: Matters of Inclusion in Ethical Deliberation
To Comply or Not?
Creating a New Path of Integrity
Further Reflections on "Self and Others
"Thinking with Dilafruz Williams about Self and OthersNel Noddings
Thinking with Nel Noddings about Self and OthersDilafruz Williams
Significant Others
Dealing with the Voice of the Community Majority
Addressing the Question of Morale
Discussion
The Interests of Self and of Others
The Self and Ethical Point of View
Integrity and Compromise
Conclusion
4 Communities Near and Far
Case
Reflections on "Communities Near and Far
"Principles, Politics, and PrudenceArthur Brown
Principles
Politics
Prudence
Postscript
Living the Life of a Teacher: Reflections on Stan's DilemmaShirley Pendlebury
Communities Near and Far
Lone Wolf
Beginnings, Middles, and Ends
Living the Life of a Teacher
Further Reflections on "Communities Near and Far
"An Addendum to "Principles, Politics, and Prudence"Arthur Brown
Teaching and TrustShirley Pendlebury
Discussion
5 Excellence and Equality
Case
Reflections on "Excellence and Equality
"Literacy Learning as Moral Learning: Excellence vs
Equality?Susan Laird
A Different Understanding ofConnie's Dilemma
Excellence: Spelling Tests or Literacy Learning
Equality through Competition or Community?
Excellence, Equality, and the Scope of Connie's ConcernsPaul Farber
Alternative Interpretations
Two Arguments for a Wider Scope
Thinking about the Next Steps
Further Reflections on "Excellence and Equality
"More than a Rejoinder toPaul Farber and Susan Laird
Response toSusan Laird and Paul Farber
Discussion
Excellence
Dignity and Simple Equality
Honor and Complex Equality
Conclusion
6 Unity and Diversity
Case
Reflections on "Unity and Diversity
"Unity and Diversity: An InterpretationMichael Katz
Unity, Diversity, and IdentityEmily Robertson
Exploring the Context
Framing the Moral Questions
Conclusion
Further Reflections on "Unity and Diversity
"Unity and Diversity: A Response to Emily RobertsonMichael Katz
Response toMichael Katz
Community andAutonomy and Emily Robertson
Discussion
A Communitarian View
The Liberal View
Cultural Relativism and Ethical Plurality
Conclusion
7 Faith and Trust
Case
Reflections on "Faith and Trust
"Ethics, Education, and the Creation/Evolution ControversyHarvey Siegel
Advice toMary Ann Massaro
"Teaching" Evolution in the SchoolsAlven Neiman
Further Reflections on "Faith and Trust
"Faith, Truth, and Philosophy
A Response to Alven NeimanHarvey Siegel
A Reply to Harvey Siegel
Philosophy and Science in EducationAlven Neiman
Discussion
Is "Truth" a Legitimate Idea?
Is "Truth" an Educational Ideal?
Conclusion
8 Of Cables and Cobwebs: Some Closing Thoughts on Ethical Judgment in Teaching
Why Ethics?
Ethical Judgment
The Role for Philosophy
Of Cables and Cobwebs
The Ethical Teacher
9 Additiona